05.19.07
Lets not jump to conclusions
Health services across the country are being reviewed. In many urban areas we have been spoiled by having an acute hospital with emergency facilities in pretty much every town. This may well have included a maternity unit, a full range of surgery and medical care, and in patient children’s services. Changes though to the way in which these services are managed and delivered are a foot and there are a number of causes including government policy, changes to workforce and the numbers of hours they work, the training they need to perform their job etc.
My current job means I am now involved with the review of maternity and children’s services in this area. The things that we know are that for reasons of clinical safety we have already had to move children’s emergency and in patient services and that another hospital trust will probably be doing the same soon. We know that the maternity units which currently take place on two sites per acute trust will also need to change, so we will look at the birthing unit ideas. In consulting we will ask real people who might have a baby and try to find out if they would want to have a baby in a place where there is no onsite paediatrician or obstetrician, we will also work with clinicians to look at the potential models of care. But if it is not going to be viable either clinically or in terms of the number of delivers (i.e. financially) then it won’t happen and services will be centralised. People might not like this idea but unfortunately we have moved away from small is beautiful and we cannot adequately staff or indeed improve services in small is beautiful. This doesn’t mean that free birthers will be the winner and it doesn’t necessarily mean that more women who shouldn’t do so will have their babies at home but what it does mean is that other people and not just doctors and midwives will get the opportunity to give their opinion and influence the decision. Cynics may think that ‘managers’ will just make the decisions and consult with no one, or at least consult then do as they please anyway, but actually I don’t think they will. We might not like the government’s choice agenda but we have it and we have to get on with it.
turnthetables said,
May 19, 2007 at 10:51 pm
How will the real people be consulted?
Julie said,
May 20, 2007 at 10:33 am
By going out to see mums both pregnant and with young children at the places that they go. From clinics and hospital places to breast feeding and baby groups, even possilbly mothercare and those kinds of places. This has upset some of the usual patient groups but as we all know this results in the same people popping up for every kind of issue.
oldbie said,
May 20, 2007 at 10:21 pm
It’s certainly good that individuals will be consulted on what they feel is best for them when it comes to the all important occasion of giving birth.
However, is there not a potential danger that the ‘uneducated’ view will take precedence over the ‘course of wisdom’?
What provisions will be in place to ensure that the ‘at risk’ women are steered towards the most appropriate venue?
Julie said,
May 20, 2007 at 10:39 pm
Well it is not about telling mums to be that we have a lovely birthing unit why don’t you use it. It is about clinicians making helping them make that decision. People need choice but that choice needs to be safe, informed and the best choice.