Life in the NHS











{February 21, 2008}   A culture of dependency?

I am beginning to think that our welfare state, whether we are users of it or employees within it is creating a culture of dependency. Life seems to be about what can be done for you, what your rights are, who you can blame for things. There is very little of the ‘I can do that’ attitude, very little ‘let me know what I can do’, very little ‘I take responsibility’. I spent some time yesterday with a reasonably new manager who is having problems with her team who are testing her out and one of which is being down right unpleasant to her. There seems to be a clear philosophy that they are the staff, they have problems and she as manager should ’sort them out’. Another colleague told a story of her team being disgruntled with the way that their agenda for change pay review had gone for them. She has tried many avenues to put things right, but ultimately she wasn’t their manager when the process started, she has done all she can to make things right but actually they need to take some responsibility. They signed off their job descriptions when they were written and now they could take out action against the employer as similar staff are paid more elsewhere but what they are waiting for is for the manager to do it all for them.Two members of my family are currently undergoing investigations for medical problems. People (and particularly the media) would have you believe that there is no choice of providers, no speedy treatment, and that generally there is a poor service. What they are finding though is that actually the health service in this country is better than you might believe. The trouble is that all too often we are fed information of everything that is not right; a drug people can’t have, a new procedure that can’t be accessed, that healthcare in the UK is provided in a grudging way and that you have to wait for it. That kind of attitude is kind of self perpetuating. If you expect the worst then maybe you will get the worst, or maybe you will be pleasantly surprised.

A patient once refused to be taught to give their own insulin since they had paid their national insurance ’stamp’ and were entitled to have it provided for them. That seems to be the attitude I encounter all too often and it doesn’t seem all that healthy to me.



Do you suppose some of the problem is there is limited talk of ethics these days. All of us human beings need to be reminded from time to time that there are degrees of moral decisions in every action we take. We have allowed too many folks to believe life is all about “me.” When in fact, to be truly happy, life must be about us.
Onehealthpro



Julie says:

Interesting thought Onehealthpro. There is definitely a me culture isn’t there? Plus we are always being told we have rights, and if we have rights then we might as well use them. Thanks for your comment.



Neil says:

Although I think there has always been a degree of ‘me’ culture, it seems that it really took off in the 80’s. Since that particular genie escaped, me-ism is rife.
To be honest, people have realised that their elected politicians, leaders and are equally or even more ‘me’ orientated, and joined in the game.
Perhaps me-ism is actually behaviour and altruism the abnormal??



Julia says:

This me-ism is rampant.Think about the L’Oreal adverts -’because you’re worth it.’ This suggests that others perhaps have less value. This also distorts our vision of the world, it promotes materialism. The meeting of basic needs such as food, shelter and health is managed with a much smaller proportion of our incomes these day and we are reluctant to return to paying more for these essentials. Rather than value the abundance of food and healthcare we are wasting much of it and are unappreciative of what is on offer.



[...] money to charity to pass on to some poor is ‘letting no-hopers survive for no reason’. On her blog this nurse says that in a welfare state like the UK “Life seems to be about what can be done for [...]



[...] money to charity to pass on to some poor is ‘letting no-hopers survive for no reason’. On her blog this nurse says that in a welfare state like the UK “Life seems to be about what can be done for [...]



Hello Julie – My name is Chloe and I work for the BBC World Service on a global discussion programme World Have Your Say. Today on our radio show we are asking does govenment help create a dependancy culture. I was interested by your post on this and wondered if you would be happy to have a chat with me about this and come on air? If you aren’t comfortable having your name broadcast we can change, so that you remain anonymous. Please do email me at Chloe.tilley@bbc.co.uk

I look forward to hearing from you



Leave a Reply

  • Spam Blocked

  • Healthcare 100

    Healthcare 100
  • Healthcare related Blogs I visit

  • disappearing John
  • Emergiblog
  • Random Acts of Reality
  • Mental Nurse
  • The Nurse Practitioner's Place
  • NP Place
  • The Shrink
  • Miss Bliss
  • Maxenurse
  • Rebirth (formerly Labor Nurse)
  • Misadventurous Melissa
  • Ward Bunny
  • The little Medic
  • Livin' Large
  • Nurse Sean
  • Busy Nurse
  • Dr Rant
  • NHS Exposed
  • NHS Exposed Blog
  • My Own Woman
  • Nurses for Reform
  • A fortunate man
  • bpositive
  • Mouse Thinks
  • Pixel RN
  • Old Age is a Bitch
  • Someday Nurse
  • American Medic in Britain
  • Impacted Nurse
  • The individual voice
  • Head Nurse
  • Jobbing Doctor
  • Ordinary World
  • Flickr Photos

    Rome Feb 2009 072

    Rome Feb 2009 072

    Rome Feb 2009 071

    Rome Feb 2009 070

    More Photos
  • Recent Posts

  • Other places to visit

    BlogMad! Varb For Me
    Stumble Upon Toolbar British Blog Directory. Add to Technorati Favorites British Blogs My Blog Directory My StumbleUpon Page Technorati

    The Healia Health Blog

    ↑ Grab this Headline Animator

    Recent Readers

    View My Profile View My Profile View My Profile View My Profile View My Profile
    View Entire Community Provided by MyBlogLog
  • Recent Comments

    BlueHornet on At last Julie gets round to…
    Yoga mat strap on Dear Gordon
    piskodrocho on At last Julie gets round to…
    Julie on Trust and personal values
    andy@yphealth on The NHS long hours culture …
  • Blog Stats

  • Weight loss progress!

  • Meta

  • ZardozZ OpenRing
    Power By Ringsurf Site Meter
  • Twitter

  • et cetera